Currently Testing Update Functions--Apologies for unexpected results

Assisting the Global Human Rights Movement in Building Social, Economic, Cultural, Civil, and Political Rights for All
 
Made possible in part by

In cooperation with:

The global human rights movement challenges the systems, structures, and institutions that create, defend, and extend oppression and repression in a society.

We are all part of the Human Rights Movement!

Featured Groups:

Race Forward and their online magazine Colorlines.

Center for Media & Democracy, and their magazine The Progressive, and their research sites ALEC Exposed and PR Watch.

The Data Center and their Research Toolkits for progressive researchers.

How Maps Change The World by framing global geography from different perspectives.


More Resources for Human Rights and Social Justice:

Home

“There is no hierarchy of oppressions.”.................— Audre Lorde
From Homophobia and Education (New York: Council on Interracial Books for Children, 1983).

Race, gender, and class are major areas of oppression that are much discussed, but less so are ability, language, size, and more. We cannot all agree on these issues, but it is appropriate to ask others to consider them seriously, and not dismiss criticism without some deep reflection. Too many have forgotten this self-reflexive habit of mind.


Building Equality Through Analyzing Systems of Oppression

by Chip Berlet

Adapted from: Chip Berlet. 2004. “Mapping the Political Right: Gender and Race Oppression in Right-Wing Movements.”
In Abby Ferber, ed., Home-Grown Hate: Gender and Organized Racism. New York: Routledge.

So called "hate" groups do not cause prejudice in the United States--they exploit it. What we clearly see as objectionable bigotry surfacing in Extreme Right movements, is actually the magnified form of oppressions that swim silently in the familiar yet obscured eddies of "mainstream" society. Racism, sexism, heterosexism, and antisemitism are the major forms of supremacy that create oppression and defend and expand inequitable power and privilege; but there are others based on class, age, ability, language, ethnicity, immigrant status, size, religion, and more. These oppressions exist independent of the Extreme Right in U.S. society.

In Racism, Sexism, Power and Ideology, Guillaumin argues that the great irony of the rise of modern egalitarianism and democracy was the ascendance of the idea that "human groups were no longer formed by divine decree or royal pleasure, but an irreversible diktat of nature." This "served to justify the system of oppression which was being built at the same time. By proposing a scheme of immanent physical causality (by race, colour, sex, nature), that system provides an irrefutable justification for the crushing of resourceless classes and peoples, and the legitimacy of the elite."

In analyzing the oppression of women, she calls for consideration of the material fact of the power relation between men and women; as well as the ideological effect of the idea that nature "is supposed to account for what women are supposed to be." It is in the teasing apart of the ideological and material practice that Guillaumin finds the most revealing critique of the essentialist naturalism that is the bulwark of many oppressive ideologies:

[I]t is very necessary to do this, for naturalism is the only mode of thought that allows the binding together in an intangible way of characteristics which if analysed--that is, forcefully dissociated--would as a matter of fact cause their relationship to become obvious. In other words, the fact would become obvious that they have a history, that they are born of specific relationships, of the links which exist between mental activities and material activities; between slavery (a material practice) and skin colour (a mental practice), between domestic exploitation (a material practice) and sex (a mental practice). From the moment that the mechanisms which create the one (mental practices) from the other are made visible, these revealed links make obvious the syncretism which merges the relationships into the deeds and shatters the affirmation that the deed and the discourse on it are one and the same thing.

According to Guillaumin "introducing the wedge of doubt into this tight block of 'law immemorial' is no small matter." She says we must "shatter the notion of instinct" that creates the syncretism of "body/slave/property" named "black" and the syncretism of "body/domestic work/property" named "women". When we look at the densely interwoven forms of oppression, subordination, and exploitation in the United States our task is to explore the links between the ideological and the material practice, not merely as an intellectual exercise that increases the subtlety of our analysis, but as a way to rip away the curtain to reveal the unfair power and privilege hiding backstage.

When analyzing oppressive systyems that undermine full equality for all we must move to a more detailed and sophisticated level of work, where the establishment of boundaries, categories, and terminology that map differences of degree allows us to increase the nuance in our analysis. Blee makes a similar argument about studying the racist movement: "We need to go further, to lay aside untested assumptions" about beliefs and attitudes of activists and ideologies of groups "and begin to systematically catalog the ideological frictions" so that "we can discern - and exploit - its weaknesses."

This challenge awaits us, whether we are studying the supremacist groups of the Extreme Right; the anti-elite anti-government conspiracism of the Patriot Movement and Tea Parties; or the gender-driven campaigns of the Christian Right. It also awaits us when we study "mainstream" centrist notions of equality, as well as those on the Political Left who claim to be fighting oppression.

In doing so, we must always recognize that theories, acts, and systems of oppression based on gender, race, sexuality, class, ethnicity, (and much more) exist throughout our society, not just in dissident or insurgent movements of the Political Right.



Notes and Sources

My research in this area would not have been possible without the support and assistance of my colleagues over the years at Political Research Associates, especially Jean Hardisty, Margaret Quigley, Surina Khan, Mitra Rastegar, Nikhil Aziz, Palak Shah, and Toby Beauchamp. In addition, I have benefited from conversations over many years with Matthew N. Lyons, Sara Diamond, Fred Clarkson, Russ Bellant, Suzanne Pharr, Loretta Ross, and Paul de Armond.

Major Sources:

Guillaumin, 1995; Goldman, 1996; Pharr, 1996a; Fraser, 1997; Wing, 2000; Rothenberg, 2001; Blee, 2001


Thanks to a discusion on Emma Rosenthal's Facbook page for stimulating revisions to this page

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Latest Civil Liberties
News Updates!

Browse Combined Feeds
Browse by Organization

Dissent is Essential!

Videos Online

When Democracy Works
Narrated by Scot Nagagawa

Vincent Harding
Students as Leaders

Herman Sinaiko
Democracy and the Obligations of Leaders and Citizens--From China in the age of the Mandarins to the Tea Parties Today


Civic Education

Elements of Democracy: The Overall Concept

Basic Concepts, from Magruder's, Chapter One

Essential Elements: The International Consensus

Democracy Activism

Frances Moore Lappé, Doing Democracy: 10 Practical Arts Handbook, Small Planet Institute.

Bill Moyer, JoAnn McAllister, Mary Lou Finley & Steve Soifer, Doing Democracy: The MAP Model for Organizing Social Movements, New Society Publishers.

Higher Education

The Democracy Imperitive
A project mobilizing higher education to support democracy

Democracy Now!: A daily independent global news hour with Amy Goodman & Juan González

Essays of Interest

Don't Abide Hate by Hussein Ibish and Brian Levin
Global Human Rights
 - 

Allied Sites

How does
Social Science
Analyze the Success
and Failure of
Social Movements?

Visit the Social Movement
Study Network Activism Pages

And learn how to
fine-tune your organizing

Democracy is not a specific set of institutions but a process that requires dissent.
Democracy is a process that assumes the majority of people,
over time, given enough accurate information, and the ability to participate in a free and open public debate,
reach constructive decisions that benefit the whole of society, and
preserve liberty, protect our freedoms, extend equality, and defend democracy.
Without dissent there is no progress in a society: Dissent is Essential!

The Building Human Rights web network incubation is supported by the Defending Dissent Foundation

Unless otherwise noted, all material on this website is copyright ©1968-2014 by Research for Progress
Site curated by Chip Berlet
The views on this website do not necessarily represent those of the sponsoring, supporting, cooperating, or listed organizations or individuals